.
THE THYLACINE IN CAPTIVITY:
- BURRELL'S THYLACINE PHOTOGRAPHS -
(page 2)
.

 
.
    Prompted by comments found in Norman Laird's papers, Carol Freeman (2005) published a paper in the Australian Zoologist entitled "Is this picture worth a thousand words? An analysis of Harry Burrell's photograph of a thylacine with a chicken", in which she argued that the thylacine shown in the images was not a living animal, but a taxidermied specimen, staged and photographed on Burrell's Namoi property, near Manilla, New South Wales.  Freeman contends that the photographs were subsequently retouched to remove any visual evidence of the staging. 

    In response, Robert Paddle (2008) published a paper in the Australian Zoologist entitled "The most photographed of thylacines: Mary Roberts' Tyenna male - including a response to Freeman (2005) and a farewell to Laird (1968)", in which he countered Freeman's claims by providing evidence that the thylacine in Burrell's photographs was indeed a living specimen, and further, that it was photographed at the Beaumaris Zoo (SB) in Hobart around 1911.

    Freeman's assertion that Burrell's thylacine photographs were retouched for publication is not in doubt.  Below are two cropped images of the same thylacine.  The image on the left has been retouched considerably to better define its features, including the removal of the shadow over the lower half of the tail.

.
thylacine - Beaumaris Zoo (SB) - circa 1911
.
Photo V8227 cropped (retouched).
Photo V8227 cropped (original).
.
    Paddle argues that the subject of the Burrell photographs is the male thylacine that Mary Roberts (founder of the Beaumaris Zoo) purchased from the bushman Bill Power on 12th August 1911.  The animal was snared near Tyenna, and its capture was recorded in the Mercury newspaper of 14th August 1911 (p. 4):

    "On Saturday forenoon there was some excitement caused at the Shamrock Hotel by the exhibition of a Tasmanian tiger, which had been captured at Tyenna, and sent to the licensee (Mr. Trebilcock).  The animal was subsequently added to the Beaumaris Zoo, Mrs. Roberts becoming the purchaser of it".

.
thylacine - Beaumaris Zoo (SB) - circa 1911
.
Roberts's thylacine (Tyenna male), 1911.
.
    The Tyenna male was, as Paddle rightly notes: "the most photographed of thylacines".  The stripe pattern of the thylacine, like the human fingerprint, is unique to each individual.  This makes the process of identification between the Burrell and Roberts thylacines one of direct comparison.
.
thylacine - Beaumaris Zoo (SB) - circa 1911
.
Roberts's thylacine (1911).
Burrell's thylacine.
.
thylacine - Beaumaris Zoo (SB) - circa 1911
.
Stripe pattern comparison between Roberts's and Burrell's thylacine.
Note: red (comma-like tail stripe), blue (bifurcated third stripe), and green (extended 4th stripe with J-shaped termination).

    It can be seen with respect to the total number of individual stripes and the unique stripe pattern identifiers, that the two thylacines represented in the photographs are, as Paddle states, one and the same.  Even the faint tracery of the collar, obvious in the photograph of Roberts's thylacine, can also be seen in the Burrell image.  The only apparent difference is that the Roberts thylacine is in its winter coat, and that of Burrell, its summer coat.

.
.
References
.
back to: Burrell's Thylacine Photographs (page 1) return to the section's introduction forward to: Burrell's Thylacine Photographs (page 3)


Search the Thylacine Museum
Site Map
Website copyright © C. Campbell's NATURAL WORLDS.
Photographs and other illustrations (where indicated) are © C. Campbell's NATURAL WORLDS.
Other photos and images are © their respective owners.
.